If you are an author or publisher negotiating a literary adaptation deal in late 2026, the most important AI protections you can get will come from your contract, not from copyright law. U.S. copyright doctrine on AI-generated works and AI training remains under active study by the U.S. Copyright Office, while private agreements—most prominently the Writers Guild of America's 2023 Minimum Basic Agreement—have already set concrete, enforceable rules. That asymmetry means the clauses you sign today define your rights far more definitively than any statute or regulation currently does.
The Dual Landscape of AI Rights: Contracts vs. Copyright
Two parallel systems currently govern AI rights in creative work, and they move at very different speeds. On one track sits copyright law, which the U.S. Copyright Office has been examining since launching an initiative in early 2023. After public listening sessions, webinars, and a Federal Register notice of inquiry in August 2023 that drew over 10,000 comments by that December, the Office has been issuing a multi-part report analyzing the issues, published as each part is completed. The scope of copyright in AI-generated works and the use of copyrighted materials in AI training remain under analysis rather than settled.
On the other track sit private negotiations, which move immediately. A Harvard Law Review analysis of the Hollywood writers' strike observed that because the amount of permissible machine creation is legally unclear, creators retain the power to choose that line for themselves through bargaining—and when Hollywood writers exercised that choice, they did not totally reject machine learning. This is why contracts are the critical battleground right now: where doctrine is murky, the deal terms fill the vacuum. That effectiveness stems from the immediate and specific nature of contracts compared with the ongoing, deliberative process of copyright law.
Guild Protections: The WGA's 2023 MBA as a Precedent
The clearest template for what enforceable AI protections look like is the Writers Guild of America's 2023 Minimum Basic Agreement. According to the WGAW, the 2023 MBA established what it describes as groundbreaking AI protections for writers, which the guild says it will strongly enforce. The core rule: neither traditional AI (technologies including those used in CGI and VFX) nor generative AI—defined as artificial intelligence that produces content including written material—is a writer, so no written material produced by either can be considered literary material under the agreement.
The MBA's protections extend beyond definitions. A company cannot require a writer to use AI software such as ChatGPT when performing writing services, and the company must disclose to the writer if any materials given to the writer have been generated by AI or incorporate AI-generated material. The WGA also reserves the right to assert that exploitation of writers' material to train AI is prohibited by the MBA or other law, and the companies agreed to meet with the guild to discuss their use and intended use of AI. These are specific contractual protections for WGA members—non-member authors cannot invoke them directly, but they can use them as a benchmark for what to demand in their own deals.




